In order: DHC Deep Cleansing Oil, Lancome Bi-Facil, Clinique Makeup Solvent Remover, Phythea Deep Cleansing Gel, DHC Soft Touch Cleansing Oil.
The cleansers and my arm with eyeliner and mascara in the middle (darker circle). The fifth blob of eyeliner is from my broken tip. Haha you can see my slippers in the 2nd pic... :)
All cleansers were applied, then rubbed around a bit, and tissued off.
FIRST TEST: DHC Deep Cleansing Oil
THIRD TEST: Clinique Rinse Off Eye Makeup Solvent
FOURTH TEST: Phythea Skin Revive Deep Cleansing Gel
FIFTH TEST: DHC Soft Touch Cleansing Oil
SIXTH TEST: La Mer Cleansing Fluid
The Final Results:
DHC Deep Cleansing Oil - Very good at removal and leaves skin moisturized. I think this has to be washed off for all of the mascara to be removed. I only used tissue in these tests.
Lancome Bi-Facil - Had better removal power than DHC by a fraction. Like DHC I think this should be washed with water to remove everything.
Clinique Rinse Off - Wow! I was shocked by this product. I didn't think it would get everything so well. It really dissolved the makeup. This isn't oil based so it removed everything without water.
Phythea Deep Cleansing Gel - I got this from my mom's friend and it's supposed to be this organic brand. I looked on the back of the bottle and the price is about 4500 yen. Pretty expensive! This didn't really remove much. I think it's ok... This probably needs water to totally remove everything.
DHC Soft Touch - The difference between this and the Deep Cleansing is that you can use this when your skin is wet. I'm not really sure if it works as well though. This was pretty good but I kind of cheated and rinsed with water.. hehe proves my point about oil-based cleansers needing water to totally remove makeup.
La Mer Cleansing Fluid - OMG! Great removal. This is an oil based cleanser and it has some pretty shimmery stuff in it (idk what it's for). I just put it on, rubbed it around, then it all came off with tissue! I am amazed :D This cleanser doesn't need water to remove makeup!
#1 - La Mer Cleansing Fluid
#2 - Clinique Rinse Off
#3 - Lancome Bi-Facil
#4 - DHC Deep Cleansing Oil
#5 - DHC Soft Touch - I cheated so the real result after tissuing was some black smearing.
#6 - Phythea Gel